The Secret Sister Gift Exchange works sort of like chain mail used to, where you would send one letter and receive many back. It works like this: six people invite six of their friends on social media to participate. All 36 people send gifts to “secret sister number one” on a list. Then it repeats for “secret sister number two” on the list, and so on. Do to the way it’s structured, you’re supposed to get back 36 gifts in return. Just like with chain mail, you may not get all 36 gifts back, but it’s still a fun idea. Here are 50 great secret sister gift ideas to send along.
This box is packed with everything your secret sister could want. It includes strawberries and apple wedges covered in chocolate, and banana bites covered in both white and semisweet chocolate.
Cost: $29.99
2. A-Maize-Ing Popcorn Variety Pack
Give your sister some extra pop. This popcorn includes four flavors of unique popcorn: raspberry lemonade, bourbon barbecue, dark chocolate caramel, and birthday cake.
Cost: $28.99
3. Rae Dunn Inspired Font Customized Text Mug
Inspired by Rae Dunn, this mug can be customized with any phrase less than 250 characters. You can personalize it with your secret sister’s name or a funny inside joke you share.
Cost: $14.24
This cookie jar will add some fun to your secret sister’s counter. With an airtight gasket lid,, it’s the perfect place to store sweet treats.
Cost: $7.48
5. Nicole Miller Mini Nail Polish Set
This set includes 15 bottles of nail polish in a variety of beautiful, eye-popping colors. They’re professional nail polishes that are easy to apply and quick to dry.
Cost: $16.99
6. LEMBO DIRECT Small Humidifier
This humidifier is only 5 inches tall, but features a large capacity. It moisturizes the air for up to 12 hours and features a warm LED night light for nighttime use.
Cost: $13.99
Keep your ear bud cables organized with this CableYoyo. Made of silicon with a magnetic center, it keeps your earbuds safe and tangle-free and ready right when you need them.
Cost: $9.95
8. 100 Movies Scratch Off Poster
Get your movie buff secret sister this poster that invites her to watch 100 iconic movies. As she watches each movie, she’ll scratch off the title to reveal colorful movie-related artwork underneath.
Cost: $15.00
9. Wrapables Animal Mini Tabletop Vacuum
Make crumbs and dust bunnies disappear with the world’s tiniest vacuum cleaner. It operates on AA batteries to provide the utmost power.
Cost: $12.99
10. LAGHCAT Mermaid Tail Blanket Crochet Mermaid Blanket
This mermaid blanket will make your secret sister feel like she’s underwater while keeping her warm on chilly nights. Made of an orlon and cotton blend, it’s super soft and cozy.
Cost: $17.98
11. Winky Lux Mini Lip Pill Kit
This kit contains five miniature lipsticks in Winky Lux’s best selling shades. It’s a great way to try out some new looks without committing to purchasing the regular size lipstick.
Cost: $16.00
12. Chalier Famous Painting Patterned Art Socks
Get your secret sister some art themed socks. This set comes complete with recreations of Starry Starry Night, the Mona Lisa, and Venus de Milo.
Cost: $10.99
13. Vtin SoundHot Q1 Waterproof Bluetooth Speaker
This mini Bluetooth speaker features a rechargeable battery that guarantees up to 10 hours playtime. It’s also completely waterproof, so your secret sister can even play her favorite tunes in the shower.
Cost: $.16.99
14. One Line A Day: A Five-Year Memory Book
Each page of this journal includes an entry for five successive years. This allows you to reflect back on a specific day over the span of five years and and reflect on all your progress.
Cost: $11.79
15. Funny Dish Towel
This dish towel is cute and funny, and it’s especially great for a secret sister who loves tacos. It’s sure to brighten up her kitchen and make her smile each time she looks at it.
Cost: $12.00
16. Funwares TriceraTaco Ultimate Dinosaur Stand
No one really needs a dinosaur taco stand, but that doesn’t mean it’s not fun. Every taco lover will adore this stand that perfectly fits a hard taco and keeps it from falling over.
Cost: $12.99
17. Nostalgia Pop-Up 2 Hot Dog and Bun Toaster
Give your secret sister a quick and easy way to make hot dogs. This toaster cooks up to two hot dogs and two buns at the same time and features an adjustable timer, so you can cook your hot dogs to your preferred level of doneness.
Cost: $24.42
18. SUN-E Whale Succulent Plant
This sweet whale container is sure to brighten up any decor. It’s made of durable and waterproof resin and is ready and waiting for a tiny succulent plant to fill it up.
Cost: $9.99
Your secret sister won’t be able to resist the sweet sloth face on this pillow. It will instantly brighten up her living room or bedroom with its cute smile and cozy fur.
Cost: $15.88
20. Frank Body Coffee Body Scrub Mini
This nutrient-rich body scrub helps removes dead skin cell for glowing, radiant skin. Packed with coffee, sweet almond oil, brown sugar, and orange oil, it’s 100% natural and vegan, and it’s and made in Australia.
Cost: $10.00
Fill your secret sister’s morning with love. This mini heart-shaped waffle maker is just what breakfast called for. It weighs just one pound and can be used to make paninis, hash browns, chaffles, and more.
Cost: 14.99
22. Mason Jar Indoor Flower Garden
With this kit, your secret sister can grow pansies, zinnias, or chamomile without soil. The jar is equipped with a wicking system that automatically brings water and nutrients up to the plant’s roots in just the right amount.
Cost: $20.00
23. Essential Oil Shower Steamers
This shower steamer gently fizzes when exposed to warm water. You can then use the steamer as a body and foot scrub while the added essential oils exfoliate and moisturize your skin.
Cost: $14.00
24. Dearfoams Pile Crisscross Slide Slippers
Designed with a fluffy crisscross top, these slippers provide the ultimate in comfort. The bottom is lightly padded for a comfy and cozy step.
Cost: $26.00
25. Silk Eye Pillow
Give your secret sister the gift of better sleep. This silk eye pillow blocks out all the light in her bedroom so she can get better, deeper sleep that leaves her feeling refreshed.
Cost: $19.99
26. Ello Devon Glass Tumbler with Silicone Sleeve
This glass tumbler is made with extra-thick, BPA-free glass. It features a real wood top and a silicone sleeve that not only protects the glass, but acts as a built-in coaster.
Cost: $12.82
This set includes six rings in your choice of silver or gold. Featuring slim bands, these rings are perfect for stacking, layering, and adding a personalized touch to your look.
Cost: $18.00
28. The Astrology of You and Me
Help your secret sister get to the bottom of all her interpersonal relationships with this astrology book. It explains the best ways to deal with each of the astrological signs, bringing energy and alignment back into her relationships.
Cost: $18.39
29. Twist Memory Foam Travel Pillow
This travel pillow contours to almost any shape to provide you with personalized support and pain relief. You can use it to support your head and neck, back, shoulder, or wherever you need it, whether you’re traveling or just relaxing on the couch at home.
Cost: $24.99
30. Nevertheless She Persisted Puzzle
From Amelia Earhart to Ruth Bader Ginsberg, this puzzle highlights 24 of history’s most empowering women. It’s an inspiring reminder of how far women have come and how much more the future holds in store.
Cost: $18.00
31. The Smallest Mini Bluetooth Speaker
Get her the gift of the smallest speaker that she can easily put in her pocket, hang on her purse, and take wherever she wants. Though it’s small, it packs a large volume and allows you to enjoy a clear, well-balanced listening experience wherever you take it.
Cost: $18.99
Freshly ground coffee tastes so much better than its preground counterparts. This grinder features an adjustable grind control, so you can set it to get fine or coarse coffee grounds depending on your needs.
Cost: $21.99
With a navy blue background and celestial accents, these coasters take you on a little trip to space right in your own living room. They provide just the right amount of glam to your next dinner party or meal.
Cost: $30.00
34. Smoko UO Exclusive Dumpling Light
Give your space a sweet glow with this food-shaped light. The small light fits right in the palm of your hand and emits a luxurious glow thanks to a battery operated light.
Cost: $16.00
35. Cat Tarot
This deck of tarot cards features a fun twist with a feline sense of humor. The set includes 78 tarot cards and a guidebook on how to use them.
Cost: $14.91
36. Hair Scalp Massager Shampoo Brush
This scalp massager may be tiny, but it provides a lot of benefits in the shower. Featuring soft silicone bristles, it helps stimulate blood flow, clean and exfoliate, and relax muscles in the scalp.
Cost: $9.99
37. Auxiwa Clip on Selfie Ring Light
Make every selfie a great photo with this selfie ring light. It provides soft illumination without harsh light whenever you want to take a photo.
Cost: $19.99
38. Tzumi PopSolo Rechargeable Bluetooth Karaoke Microphone
Turn any cellphone into a karaoke machine with this Bluetooth microphone. It provides up to five hours of clear, quality singing time and features a built-in phone holder so you can see the lyrics to your favorite songs.
Cost: $19.99
This llama is the perfect tea infuser. Just fill with your favorite loose leaf and set inside a mug with hot water for a perfectly infused cup of tea every time.
Cost: $10.95
40. Bloomingville Acacia Wood Hedgehog Cutting Board
Made from real acacia wood, this cutting board is both beautiful and durable. It features a sweet hedgehog design that’s perfect for animal lovers.
Cost: $13.44
41. Savvy Infusion Water Bottle
Give your secret sister an easy way to upgrade plain drinking water. This bottle features an inner sleeve that allows you to infuse your water with your favorite combo of fruits.
Cost: $15.95
42. Brownlow Gifts Galvanized Metal Round Serving Tray
This vintage style serving tray is made with galvanized tin and features jute handles. It’s great for entertaining or just as a catch-all for odds and ends around the house.
Cost: $15.94
43. Umbra Trigg Hanging Planter Vase
These planters bring a touch of geometric design to your home. They’re perfect for filling with your favorite succulents, air plants, mini cactus, or even artificial blooms.
Cost: $14.28
Made of 100% recycled bamboo, this bedside shelf is super sturdy and can hold up to 33 pounds. It features a cup holder, a cable management slot, and detachable side panels for the perfect multi-functional nightstand.
Cost: $19.99
What book lover doesn’t love the smell of the library? This soy candle is infused with the scents of mahogany, oak, and vintage books to take you right back to your favorite place.
Cost: $22.00
Featuring 50 prompts and exercises, these cards help you learn to appreciate the little things. Over time, they also help you cultivate a sense of self-care and acceptance as you go through life.
Cost: $16.95
Have you ever wanted to be a giant burrito or quesadilla? Well now you can with this burrito blanket. Made of high quality flannel fabric, it’s super soft and cozy as well.
Cost: $18.99
Bring your love of biking into the kitchen with this bicycle pizza cutter. It features both front and back wheels made from stainless steel, with a sharp edge for effortless cutting on even the thickest of pizza crusts.
Cost: $14.95
49. Nostalgia Indoor Electric Stainless Steel S’mores Maker
Bring back some nostalgia with this s’mores maker. It features an electric flameless heater, with a four compartment serving tray for chocolate, marshmallows, and graham crackers.
Cost: $19.99
50. Dash Electric Mini Griddle
This mini griddle can make crepes, pancakes, grilled cheese, and so much more. It features a four-inch non-stick cooking surface that heats evenly and cleans up quickly for easy cooking.
Cost: $9.99
If you’re participating in a secret sister gift exchange, pick up one of these great gifts to send along. If you’re lucky, you’ll get 36 gifts in return!
